The chalkstreams: how bad is it?

River Test - Whitchurch Fulling Mill

River Test – Whitchurch Fulling Mill

Nether Wallop Mill, Hampshire, England

Well, actually surprisingly good. This week I have done a tour of the Itchen, Test, Avon and Dorset stream catchments. I have definitely seen rivers this full and water meadows this flooded twice before in the past two decades but the real difference is how long the water is laying and the carnage to the trees.

I really cannot believe how many trees are down; not just spindly ones but huge trees and especially poplars. There is a section down on the Allen that looks positively lunar with the huge craters alongside tree trunks that all lay in exactly the same direction clearly felled by a vicious spike of wind that blew through. Poplars were a bit of a cash crop in the 1960’s and 70’s planted and harvested for matchstick production, but when that stopped they were just left to grow and are now vulnerable being well past maturity. Fortunately these particular trees have fallen away from the river, but elsewhere we are having real problems with trees. Usually with the help of farm machinery we can get out even the biggest trees but our difficulty at the moment is that no tractor can get near the river without getting stuck. So, it is with winches, grim determination and heavy duty waders plus a good dose of ingenuity that the keepers are gradually clearing the rivers. Firewood anyone?

On a more positive note you will see from the photos that generally the rivers are back within their banks and what has struck me is how clear the water is, albeit pounding through at many times the normal rate. Even on the upper reaches where you’d normal wade nonchalantly you need to think twice before getting in. As for the fish well they don’t care; after the winter spawning they are very active and far more visible than in a normal year. The mild weather is encouraging the reeds and plants along the margins to shoot early and there have been staggering hatches of olives. On the Wylye I had to swat away clouds that were almost choking me.

So, what’s the verdict? Well, as far as the fish and the ecology of the chalkstreams everything is as it should be – this is how the water meadow system was designed to cope. But as for us anglers things are trickier. The real problem at the moment, and I suspect until into early April, is getting along or to the banks. All are waterlogged to some degree, with plenty of places were the water is still Wellington boot deep . With every day the worst is receding and I expect everywhere to open on schedule as planned, but if you are venturing out wear waders (even for bank fishing) and take a long handled net. If it is a wading beat go carefully especially getting in and out as it is often hard to tell where the bank ends and the river starts.

I know it is tempting to look on the bleak side of the floods, but it is worth casting our minds back two years this week to when I attended a crisis drought summit in Berkshire. The media had been filled with TV reporters standing in the dried up River Kennet at Hungerford and we were told that it ‘would take generations’ for the flows to return. Mother Nature always, but always has the last laugh.

About lifeofachalkstream

I am a professional fly fisherman, fishing guide and author living in a restored water mill in Hampshire. I write a bi-weekly blog charting the oddities and events that come my way living life on a river. In 2014 Harper Collins published my first book Life of a Chalkstream and in 2017 the next will be out, this time about the otters who share my life at the mill.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The chalkstreams: how bad is it?

  1. stourfisher says:

    Hi Simon. When I did a film for ‘Tight Lines’ a few weeks back on the Royalty, Itchen and Test it was truly awful. As you say, trees down everywhere. The bank damage is dreadful. Another massive concern from the keepers I interviewed (Clayton Moorhouse at Lower Itchen and Jon Hall on the Test at Broadlands) was the damage that had been done to fish lies where the extra water has simply scoured them away. In terms of fishing though, damage to weed beds could be the biggest problem as the summer arrives. There simply won’t be anywhere for the fish to sit, and for the bugs to populate.

    • Hi! Many thanks for the post, but sorry to say I missed your film. It was a shame you were not able interview some of the keepers higher up the chalkstream systems; at Whitchurch Fulling Mill (pictured in the blog) Mark will have to cut at least once, possibly twice before the season starts! As this stage I think the weed growth is very much determined by the depth of water. Two foot (ish) or less and no problem. More than that the depth has to subside and/or the light intensity increase to get the river bed. I have done some research on the effects of floods to both spawning and invertebrates. Swedish research showed brown trout thriving in the years immediately after floods. As for invertebrates it was the gammarus who lost out, the rest being able to cope fine. Spawning showed not ill effects and in fact befitted; the only time floods have negative impact is on very steep rivers according to brook trout returns in Canada. So it seems that quite literally, every cloud has a silver lining ……

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s